Transformations that require to provide specific value


We are working on a contract renewal with a customer that is driving the process with clear goals and expectations. They want to renew just for 2 years and have a YoY savings of 6%.

Initial approach

We were requested to look into the current solutions, look for improvements and identify transition or transformation projects that enable a new contract with the 6% savings.

We have done the analysis and after that we have done some specific conclusions and a generic conclusion about the situation.

What is the typical cycle of CAPEX investment where you are looking for ROI?

  • 5 Years contract.
  • Transition & transformations during the first 2 years.
  • Positive return in the fith year.
  • Consider basic calculation/benefits, I have not added any additional benefit as time to market, or other benefits.

In my analysis I have created simple scenarios:

  • Scenario 1: plain scenario, as baseline for comparison (I do not do anything).
  • Scenario 2: T&T with 10% on 5 years contract with small YoY reduction.
  • Scenario 3: T&T with 10% on 5 years contract with a more agressive YoY reduction.


  • When creating T&T programs with specific returns, you require some time to
  • T&T should not be more than 10% – 12% of the overall price of your solution.
  • In environments where automation is deployed and there are not other major angles to improve, a different approach is required (change of solution with a business case that requires more CAPEX and years to obtain ROI).
  • Hidden cost is an obstacle to be competitive.
  • In our case, it is mathematically not possible to propose a T&T project to recover the ROI is just 2 years (if you are not removing a clear major issue). The only available approach is to accelerate continuous improvement on the existing services.

Leave a Comment